Is an off-peak membership worth it?
An off-peak membership is the same gym for less money, at the hours the gym finds hardest to fill. It’s a good deal if those are hours you can use.
Start with when you go
Look back over your last 30 days and split your visits in two: the ones that fell inside the off-peak hours, and the ones that didn’t. The second group is what you’d be giving up, unless you can move them.
Off-peak hours differ from gym to gym. Commonly they’re weekday daytimes, with early mornings, evenings and sometimes weekends kept for full members. Get the exact hours in writing before you compare anything.
The sum
Say the full membership is £45.00 a month and off-peak is £32.00, and you go 8 times in 30 days. On the full membership each visit costs £5.55. The table shows off-peak if some of those visits can’t be moved and are lost.
| Peak visits lost | Visits you keep | Cost per visit, off-peak | Against full |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | 8 | £3.95 | Off-peak is lower |
| 1 | 7 | £4.51 | Off-peak is lower |
| 2 | 6 | £5.26 | Off-peak is lower |
| 3 | 5 | £6.31 | Full is lower |
| 4 | 4 | £7.89 | Full is lower |
At these prices you can lose up to 2 of your 8 visits and still pay less for each one you keep. The general rule is that off-peak wins on cost per visit when the share of visits you keep is bigger than the off-peak price as a share of the full price.
You save £13.00 a month either way. The table tells you whether you’re saving money or just buying fewer visits.
What the sum leaves out
- The visits you’d want back. A lost visit isn’t only a number. If the Saturday morning session is the one you look forward to, a lower price won’t make up for it.
- Classes. The popular ones are often in the evening. Check whether the classes you’d go to run inside off-peak hours.
- Turning up at the wrong time. Ask what happens if you arrive outside your hours. Some gyms turn you away and some charge a top-up.
- Bank holidays and school holidays. Some gyms treat these as peak.
- Switching back. Find out whether you can move up to full membership later without a new joining fee or a new minimum term.
Who it suits
It suits people whose days are their own: shift workers, people who work from home, students, parents with children at school, and anyone retired. It rarely suits a nine-to-five with a commute, however good the price looks.
A quieter gym is a benefit the price list doesn’t mention. If you’ve only ever been at six in the evening, try a day pass at eleven in the morning before you decide.
Check it against your own record
The app’s History lists every visit with the day and time you arrived, so you can count the ones that would have fallen outside off-peak hours. After you switch, your cost per visit over the last 30 days shows whether you’re better off.
Updated . Prices on this page are examples, not quotes from any gym or club.